It was all over the St. Louis television news: the air quality in Madison County is worse than any other area in the U.S. except Los Angeles!
Hurry to your bomb shelters and pull out the gas masks! The air we breathe is killing us!
Whoa! It makes for great TV, but let’s get to the bottom of the story.
First, and foremost in my assessment, the EPA data released yesterday was from a study done in 2002! Yep, it takes the EPA seven years to crunch their numbers and release findings. Geez, I’m glad they didn’t find pollution with fast acting effects!
Second, though the pretty people on TV didn’t tell you this, the seven year old findings found three census tracts where the pollution levels were exceptionally high. Guess where the census tracts were? Right next to the steel mill in Granite City! Well, duh! That’s like reporting the smell is bad next to a hog farm.
What, you might ask, is a census tract? According to the U.S. Census Bureau, “Census tract population criteria will be 1,500 to 8,000 persons.” So, thanks to our friends at the EPA and our friends in TV news, we alarm more than 265,000 county residents with seven year old data that, at the time, affected between 4,500 and 24,000 people! So at the max, about 10% of county residents were affected in 2002.
And third, had the EPA spent some time in Madison County anytime recently, they would know about the millions of dollars spent in the last five years on cleaning up the air in our county, and specifically the three census tracts in Granite City. U.S. Steel, the now-owners of what we all refer to as Granite City Steel, has spent millions on upgrades to clean up the air and to comply with current EPA requirements. That’s OK, we’ll hear about it in the data they release in 2016.
And lastly, since this report reflected negatively on Madison County, Illinois it makes great TV news. If the same findings had been released about St. Louis City (or county) the TV folks would have had a slew of official “rebuttals and demands for new studies” from every spokesperson they could videotape. But this was bad for those residents from the “metro east”, so we’ll pile it on. So much for fair and balanced reporting.
So take heart! We are not breathing ourselves to death in Madison County. Relax and take a deep breath. I feel better already.



